Insurance Company |
Quote Method |
Purchase Method |
Estimated Monthly Cost ($) |
Agent Needed |
Policy Access |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Progressive |
Online |
Website |
$124 |
No |
24/7 Access |
GEICO |
Phone |
Direct Call |
$108 |
No |
Online Dashboard |
State Farm |
Mobile App |
Mobile Purchase |
$137 |
No |
Mobile Access |
Liberty Mutual |
Website |
Online Purchase |
$153 |
No |
Policy Management |
Allstate |
Online |
Direct Website |
$171 |
No |
24/7 Customer Service |
Policy Task |
Online |
Mobile App |
Phone |
Typical Time |
Agent Needed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Get Quote |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
5 Minutes |
No |
Buy Policy |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
12 Minutes |
No |
Change Coverage |
Yes |
Yes |
No |
8 Minutes |
No |
File Claim |
Yes |
No |
Yes |
15 Minutes |
No |
Download ID Card |
Yes |
No |
No |
3 Minutes |
No |
Purchase Step |
Typical Time |
Information Needed |
Online Completion |
Agent Needed |
Cost ($) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Start Quote |
4 Minutes |
Driver Info |
Yes |
No |
$0 |
Coverage Selection |
10 Minutes |
Vehicle Info |
Yes |
No |
$104 |
Discount Review |
6 Minutes |
Discount Details |
Yes |
No |
$5 |
Payment |
8 Minutes |
Payment Method |
Yes |
No |
$150 |
Proof of Insurance |
3 Minutes |
Email Address |
Yes |
No |
$0 |
Insurance Company |
Direct Quote |
Online Purchase |
Mobile Access |
Monthly Example ($) |
Customer Service |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Travelers |
$135 |
Yes |
Yes |
$142 |
24/7 Support |
American Family |
$177 |
Yes |
No |
$196 |
11 AM – 11 PM |
USAA |
$89 |
Yes |
Yes |
$92 |
24/7 Support |
Erie |
$115 |
Yes |
No |
$120 |
9 AM – 5 PM |
Nationwide |
$164 |
Yes |
Yes |
$178 |
24/7 Chat |
Option |
Quote Source |
Monthly Cost ($) |
Purchase Method |
Policy Changes |
Intermediary |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Direct Company |
Website |
$124 |
Online |
Yes |
No |
Independent Agent |
Agent |
$137 |
Phone |
Yes |
Yes |
Captive Agent |
Agency |
$145 |
In-Person |
No |
Yes |
Online Direct |
Website |
$108 |
Self-Service |
Yes |
No |
Broker |
Broker |
$156 |
Mix |
Yes |
Yes |