Can You Have Two Car Insurance Policies in New York: Multiple 2 or 3 Vehicle Coverage Discounts

By Anand • 1 minute read

Combined vs Separate Vehicle Insurance in New York
Vehicle Setup
Separate Cost ($)
Combined Cost ($)
Monthly Savings ($)
Annual Savings ($)
Policy Structure
2 Vehicles
$182
$169
$13
$156
Separate Policies
3 Vehicles
$278
$240
$38
$456
Combined Vehicles
2 Vehicles
$150
$140
$10
$120
Same Insurer
2 Vehicles
$210
$195
$15
$180
Different Insurers
3 Vehicles
$330
$295
$35
$420
Multi-Car Policy
3 Vehicle Car Insurance Discounts in New York
Vehicle 1 ($)
Vehicle 2 ($)
Vehicle 3 ($)
Discount (%)
Combined Monthly Cost ($)
Annual Savings ($)
$92
$105
$117
11%
$292
$360
$100
$150
$130
16%
$332
$486
$85
$120
$138
9%
$343
$305
$110
$95
$145
13%
$337
$400
$96
$130
$106
24%
$270
$480
Annual Savings With 2 or 3 Vehicle Car Insurance in New York
Vehicles
Separate Cost ($)
Multi-Car Cost ($)
Monthly Savings ($)
Annual Savings ($)
3-Year Savings ($)
2
$198
$180
$18
$216
$648
3
$280
$245
$35
$420
$1,260
2
$175
$150
$25
$300
$900
3
$310
$290
$20
$240
$720
2
$165
$155
$10
$120
$360
Two Different Insurers in New York
Vehicle Setup
Insurer 1 Cost ($)
Insurer 2 Cost ($)
Combined Cost ($)
Multi-Car Discount
Annual Total ($)
2 Vehicles
$134
$125
$259
7%
$3,108
3 Vehicles
$88
$95
$183
11%
$2,196
2 Vehicles
$120
$130
$250
9%
$3,000
3 Vehicles
$145
$115
$260
13%
$3,120
2 Vehicles
$197
$180
$377
16%
$4,524
2 vs 3 Vehicle Car Insurance Costs in New York
Vehicles Insured
Cost Before Discount ($)
Discount (%)
Discount Amount ($)
Monthly Cost ($)
Annual Cost ($)
2
$230
10%
$23
$207
$2,484
3
$310
12%
$37.20
$272.80
$3,273.60
2
$150
15%
$22.50
$127.50
$1,530
3
$289
20%
$57.80
$231.20
$2,774.40
2
$190
8%
$15.20
$174.80
$2,097.60

Anand