Dutch is one of the most unique languages in the world, and is often considered along with German to be particularly challenging for the newly acquainted. So what is easier to learn Dutch or German?
Perhaps the most reassuring thing about the Dutch language is how closely it resembles English, which in turn also has Germanic roots. Speaking both English and German will give you a considerable advantage when learning Dutch. However, while Dutch shares many similarities with English and German, it’s important to understand where the similarities end and nuances begin–and then embrace them! Fluency may not come right away, but when questioning what is easier to learn German or Dutch, it all comes down to practice.
There’s a common joke among historical linguists that if William the Conquerer hadn’t invaded England and introduced the Norman culture–namely the language–it’s very likely that English and Danish would be all but interchangeable. Because of the heavy French influence on the English language, however, those similarities are somewhat diminished.
Many people who have studied Dutch note how closely it resembles the decadent Shakespearian or Irish English in many aspects, namely pronunciations. (For example, “the” is pronounced as “de”.) Many words like “open” are the same in both languages, and one speaker notes that Dutch spoken in passing on the streets could very well pass for swiftly spoken English.
Another example is the word “sorry.” In English we often used “sorry” to either indicate regret or conversely, that we didn’t catch something that was said to us. These “loan words” can also be found in the Dutch language, which can often be confusing until you get the hang of them. Don’t worry if you occasionally mix up certain word uses, as that’s entirely normal. Many Dutch words are written the same but pronounced differently, which can also be problematic in the early stages of learning the language.
Here’s a fun thing to try: take a typical Dutch word and play around with removing the double vowels, adding -e’s, replacing g’s at the end with y’s, etc, and seeing just how much the context still remains even in German. With a little imagination it’s easy to see just how much the languages have in common!
When determining what is easier to learn Dutch or German, it’s easy to get hung up on which one’s “best,” when in fact they are mutually intelligible for the most part. While Dutch may have fewer complications when taken at face value, any language’s accessibility depends on the individual. And as always, immersion can make all the difference.
Learning to speak German in Berlin and Dutch in Amsterdam, as opposed to inside a classroom across the ocean, will understandably make a world of difference, and all but nullify the “which one is easier” argument. Daily practice through conversing and cultural absorption is how many people claim to have mastered a second language. (If you can’t go the geographic immersion route though, don’t lose heart!)
Despite their many similarities, it never hurts to explore some of the key differences between Dutch and German:
Dutch also has differing end verb orders. Although the second verb may be placed at the end of many situations in both Dutch and German, Dutch more closely resembles English in this instance, when end verbs like Hij komt niet, omdat hij vandaag moet werken (He is not coming, because he has to work today). In German this would mean ending with arbeiten muss, which would then be reversed. You can do both when speaking Dutch, while German only allows for the second form. For example, “Zij zei dat ze het niet (heeft gevonden)/(gevonden heeft” > “She said that she hasn’t found it.”
Obviously there are many more differences to be found in both the Dutch and German languages, but it helps to remember that the two languages share a common ancestor, and aren’t completely foreign to each other. If you’re wondering what is easier to learn German or Dutch, rest assured that’s entirely up to you! Everyone learns languages a little differently; some pick them up right away, while others need a bit more time and practice.
Fortunately there are a variety of tools available today to help you master the Dutch language (or any language for that matter!), such as online courses, mobile apps, and traditional tutoring and classroom structure. Dutch may seem a bit tricky at first, but with some dedication you’ll be chatting in no time.